The Sweet Battle for the Sachertorte: Demel vs. Sacher

by | 28 January 2025

Vienna, the city of music, art, and… cake! No treat is as iconic as the Sachertorte, a decadent chocolate cake loved worldwide. But did you know there’s a bitter rivalry behind this sweet delicacy? Two of Vienna’s most prestigious establishments, Café Demel and Hotel Sacher, have fought for years over the title of the “true” Sachertorte maker. Let’s delve into this delicious controversy.

The Origin of the Sachertorte

The history of the Sachertorte begins in 1832 when the young pastry chef Franz Sacher created the cake for Klemens Wenzel von Metternich, the Austrian state chancellor. The cake was an instant success, and Franz’s son, Eduard Sacher, later opened the famous Hotel Sacher, where the cake became a staple on the menu.

The Dispute Begins

Demel

The dispute began when Eduard Sacher further honed his skills at the renowned pastry shop Demel. Here, he introduced a variant of the Sachertorte, leading to confusion over who actually made the authentic version. Both establishments claimed to possess the original recipe, resulting in a legal battle that lasted decades.In the 1960s, the situation escalated into a lawsuit. Hotel Sacher and Café Demel fought in court over the rights to the name “Original Sachertorte.” After years of legal battles, a compromise was reached: Hotel Sacher was granted the right to call their cake the “Original Sachertorte,” while Demel could name their version the “Eduard-Sacher-Torte.”

Sacher

Today, visitors to Vienna can enjoy both versions of the Sachertorte. At Hotel Sacher, you get a cake with a thick layer of apricot jam between the cake and the chocolate glaze, while Demel’s version has the jam directly under the glaze. Both are delicious in their own way and offer a unique taste experience.

Conclusion

The rivalry between Café Demel and Hotel Sacher has only made the Sachertorte more famous. It’s a beautiful example of how history, culture, and gastronomy come together in the streets of Vienna. So next time you’re in the city, why not try them both and decide for yourself which is your favorite?

David Pokorny was born in beautiful Vienna, but grew up in the Netherlands. In 2020 he decided to return to Vienna to start My Vienna Tours. In these blogs David shares personal experiences from this beautiful city.

Other blogs

The History of Vienna Through the Eyes of a Cyclist

The History of Vienna Through the Eyes of a Cyclist

Every time I hop on my bike and ride through the streets of Vienna, I feel the city's history come to life. Vienna is a city where the past and present uniquely meet. As you cycle past historic buildings like the Hofburg and the Vienna State Opera, you not only see...

read more

New: Luxury eBike Adventure in Vienna

Our luxury eBikes provide a comfortable and stylish ride, in a group of up to 7 people

€ 64,- per person

Bike tour
Vienna Complete

All famous sights in and around the beautiful centre of Vienna

€ 45,- per person

Walking or bike
Private tour

A private tour through Vienna, walking or cycling

from € 49,- per person

School Bike Tour
for students

This short and powerful tour is perfect for young explorers who want to explore the city

price on request

Discover our full range of tours

We have more tailor-made tours for groups that can be booked on request.